Skip to main content

About this Show

Special Report With Bret Baier

News/Business. Bret Baier. (2012) New.

NETWORK

DURATION
01:00:00

RATING

SCANNED IN
San Francisco, CA, USA

SOURCE
Comcast Cable

TUNER
Virtual Ch. 760 (FOX NEWS HD)

VIDEO CODEC
mpeg2video

AUDIO CODEC
ac3

PIXEL WIDTH
1280

PIXEL HEIGHT
720

TOPIC FREQUENCY

Benghazi 11, Petraeus 5, Colorado 5, Washington 5, Iran 5, David Petraeus 4, Boehner 4, John Boehner 4, Iraq 4, Afghanistan 4, Obama 3, The F.b.i. 3, U.s. 3, Us 3, Broadwell 2, New Hampshire 2, America 2, Oceanside 2, Iowa 2, Sandy 2,
Borrow a DVD
of this show
  FOX News    Special Report With Bret Baier    News/Business. Bret  
   Baier.  (2012) New.  

    November 9, 2012
    3:00 - 4:00pm PST  

3:00pm
out his house on the shore. we hope it came out all right. we know it's important to him. >> andrea: that is it for us on "the five." thank you for watching. have a great weekend. see you next week. >> bret: a personal scandal leads to the resignation of one of the obama administration's most respected figures. this is "special report." ♪ >> bret: good evening. i'm bret baier. talk about a november surpris surprise. c.i.a. director general david petraeus is out tonight. just three days after president obama won re-election. petraeus says the reason isen extramarital affair. this is one of those stories that virtually no one saw coming. we begin with ed henry. >> reporter: officials were stunned when general petraeus came to the president and told him that he wanted to step
3:01pm
down. he has had a long distinguished military record of decades, architect of the surge in iraq. you will remember. in 2007 under president bush. came back and became the commander on the ground in afghanistan against president obama. the general has come under fire for the c.i.a. role in benghazi terror attack, people close to him tonight insist the resignation had nothing to do with the ips dept. this is a personal failing that he talked about today in a statement saying after being married for over 37 years i showed extremely poor judgment by engaging in an extramarital affair. such behavior is unacceptable as a husband and leader of an organization such as ours. this afternoon, the president graciously accepted my resignation. over the years president and petraeus clashed. there was especially speculation that petraeus could be vice presidential nominee on the republican side
3:02pm
but that never happened. they did come together after stanley mcchrystal stepped down because of the unformnate comments he made to "rolling stone" magazine and general petraeus put the differences aside and went to battlefield and served as commanderer on the ground in afghanistan. president singled him out and praised him saying he is one of the outstanding general officers of his generation. helping our military adapt to new challenges. leading the men and women in the uniform through a remarkable period of service in iraq and afghanistan. where he helpe helped the natiot war on path to responsible end. director of the centralgency hed with characteristic and intellectual rigor. dedication and patriotism. that is from the president. feinsteidianne feinstein is tont saying while she does not excuse the general behavior, she regrets that the president accepted the resignation because she thinks he is critical in that job. so important in that job.
3:03pm
the last thing the white house wanted to do is search for new c.i.a. director. >> bret: we'll head back in a minute. thank you. of course, general petraeus was one of the first to brief lawmakers following the deadly attack on the u.s. mission in libya two months ago. chief intelligence correspondent herron has the latest to than investigation. good evening. >> reporter: thank you, bret. fox news told that the c.i.a. director will not testify next week. this is expected to be one of the most intense hearings on capitol hill on the benghazi scandal. >> at the white house briefing, spokesman jay carney pushed back on allegation the administration was not forthcoming on the benghazi attack. specifically what happened on september 11 at the white house as the president met with defense secretary and joint chiefs. >> made aware of the developments throughout the evening and days ensuing. i'm not sure what your question is specifically. >> while they are not independent investigations,
3:04pm
carney pointed to the state department internal review, public timeline from the defense department that lays out the military response. similar briefing last week by intelligence officials on the c.i.a. emergency response. >> next week, half dozen hearings or briefings are scheduled including the state department under-secretary patrick kennedy charged with jeff seeing the staff facilities and operation and eric boswell charged with the jeff seeing the diplomatic security for benghazi and other foreign missions. the administration emphasizes the public right to know what unfolded in benghazi, all of next week session except for one will be closed. the state department spokeswoman said it was congress' call. >> my understanding they wanted to have a conversation that incorporated classified information including intelligence reporting. >> some classified documents are available at a classified meeting room on capitol hill. senator bob corker said they were not remackable but he wants more clarity from the hearings next week.
3:05pm
>> we want to understand what was happening. was there a failure if intelligence information? i have had conversations with petraeus. people are still upset that the misleading comments that were made were made. >> bret: they told fox news there was genuine shock among the agency employees over sudden and abrupt departure of petraeus. on capitol hill, the lawmakers were, "flabbergasted" at the resignation and question whether they may still call or subpoena petraeus to testify now that he is a private citizen. bret? >> bret: we're justing more about this. the petraeus affair apparently was with his biographer. woman by the name of paul ab broadwell. was revealed -- there is a picture of her. in the course of an f.b.i. the f.b.i. was investigating a broader case unrelated to this. and in the course of that investigation, broadwell name came up. the f.b.i. followed that lead in doing so. petraeus's name came up. the f.b.i. for some reason was concerned that perhaps
3:06pm
petraeus was some sort of victim and perhaps blac blackmailing scheme. then a security breach may have been involved and that led to this. it seems like it's starting to un. the fact that f.b.i. involved is significant. >> we have seen resignation of a public figure with intimate knowledge of what happened in benghazi. we are seeing that this is not putting a lid on the situation. in fact, we're seeing it intensify. even step up to another level because if he testify on the hill. he could voluntarily go to the hill. he could be subpoenas. if he goes to any circumstances, he may lawyer up under the circumstances. >> bret: we'll continue to follow every aspect of this. thank you. >> you're welcome. >> bret: now to the fiscal cliff. just 53 days away. both president obama and house speaker john boehner are advocating compromise, yet sticking to their guns on
3:07pm
taxes. again, chief white house correspondent ed henry. >> even as president obama suggested the campaign is over by inviting congressional leaders to white house for fiscal cliff negotiations next week -- >> it is time to get back to work. >> he left the impression the campaign continues as the white house invited 200 supporters to the east room. for what republicans dismissed as a rally. >> we can't just cut our way to prosperity. if we're serious about reducing the deficit, we have to combine spending cuts with revenue. that means asking the wealthiest americans to pay a little more in taxes. >> the president's first public comment since election night came less than two hours after house speaker john boehner said yet again today he is ready to deal. >> this is an opportunity for the president to lead. this is his moment. the president claimed one for his plan. the spending cut mixed with
3:08pm
tax increases. >> i want to point out this was a central question in the election. on tuesday night, we found out that the majority of americans agree with my approach. >> boehner insisted otherwise noting the message he took by the election in which the republicans campaign against the tax increases and maintain control of the house was that tax hikes will kill jobs. >> everyone wants to get the economy moving again. everyone wants to get more americans back to work depen. it will slow down our ability to create jobs that everyone says he wants. >> the stalemate leads both sides no closer to a deal to avoid the fiscal cliff. $700 billion in spending cuts and an end to the tax rates coming at the end of the year. boehner is under pressure from conservatives to not give in on the tax rate increases he is willing to end deductions that could raise the tax
3:09pm
revenue. the president is getting pressure from the left. "new york times" columnist paul krugman going so far today to suggest the white house should be willing to daniel the economy to make their point with republicans. writing, "what should he do?" just say no and go over the cliff if necessary. the president said today he is open to giving in to a point. >> i want to be clear. i'm not wedded to every detail of my plan. i'm open to compromise. i am open to new ideas. i'm committed to solving our fiscal channel. i refuse to accept any approach that isn't balanced. >> the president broke with tradition not holding a news conference quickly after his re-election. aides point out he will take question next wednesday at the white house. that will coo inside with congress to come back in session to shape the debate. it will be his first full-fledged news conference since june. bret?
3:10pm
>> bret: double duty tonight. ed, thank you. the most retweeted image of all time. who is in it? we'll explain in grapevine. up next, picture of confusion over legalized marijuana in colorado. mom always got good nutriti to taste great.
3:11pm
3:12pm
she was a picky eater. well, now i'm her dietitian, and last year, she wasn't eating so wel so i recmended boost complete nutritional drink to help her get the nutrition she was missing. and now she drinks it every day. well, it tastes great! [ male announcer ] boost has 26 essential vitamins and minerals, including calcium and vitamin d to support strong bones, and 10 grams of protein to help maintain muscle. all with a delicious taste. [ dietitian ] now, nothing keeps mom from doing what she loves -- being my mom. [ male announcer ] stay strong, stay active with boost.
3:13pm
>> bret: earlier in week, washington an colorado became the first in the nation to approve recreational use of marijuana. today, colorado governor was supposed to find out how it fits with federal law prohibiting that sort of thing. correspondent alicia acuna is watching from denver. >> now what? the question over governor hickenlooper after voters approved historic measure. >> our voters want marijuana to be regulated. like alcohol. >> hickenlooper talked with eric holder about the issue today. state leaders have a lot of questions about dealing with a
3:14pm
new constitutional amendment decriminalizing marijuana. >> there are a lot of laws i think are stupid that i support and provided a vice on every day. >> colorado attorney general southers opposed the amendment that won 55% of the vote. it allows those age 21 years and older to possess up to an ounce of marijuana, grow six pot plants naned the long-term wording allowed for stores to sell it to recreational users. the law contradicts federal policy. >> owe it to the people of colorado to state intentions. are you going to prosecute? because people going in business need to know that. >> constitutional law professor specializes in marijuana law. he says colorado and washington state passals are a major transition beyond medical use.
3:15pm
>> we could see the federal government come down strongly on what is happening here. we could see the sort of state experimenting with the legalization that we have seen over the past three or four years. or we could see negotiated settlement. >> fox news contacted the white house and department of justice for reaction. in a statement the d.o.j. said in part that the department enforcement of the controlled substances act remains up changed. we are reviewing the ballot initiative and have no additional comment at this time. there is no residency requirement in law, which has some of the business minded thinking tourism. we heard ideas such as weed related bus tours that scares the daylights out of those worried about the state's reputation. >> bret: alicia acuna live in denver. thank you. the dow gained 4. nasdaq up 9.
3:16pm
'n' 'n' up 2. new yorkers have gasoline rationing system. utility crews in the northeast seem to make progress in turning the lights back on. senior correspondent rick leventhal reports from oceanside new york. not enough progress for those without electricity. >> 30 years. gone. just like that. >> trash trucks reach town of oceanside on new york long island. for the first time since sandy hit 11 days ago. residents are still in the dark. >> we got no response from anyone. tan sation people. we got no direction. >> hundreds of hows are without power, heat or when they will get back online. one long island utility company said it was running out of supplies, outraged the new york governor. >> look at what he does it comes down to wire and poles. and crews and trucks.
3:17pm
these are the things you want to have. how can you run out of poles? >> in new york city, gas rationing began today. cars with the even number plate film on even number days. odd number plate fill up on odd number days. ease long line and short tempers. >> that make sense. it would have useed up. you wouldn't have had the long lines. >> housing is a growing concern. fema trying to provide shelter for 95% people. you wake up and you're okay then in a second it hits you that this happened and you don't have a place of your own anymore. it's de stating. you always think it won't be you. then it is. >> one thing there seems to be plenty of, generosity. train with supplies from louisiana to new jersey packed by a community who knows something about weathering mother nature. >> all the images of new
3:18pm
jersey mad them feel like they want to do something. so they organized effort on facebook. >> donations are appreciated. but they won't turn the lights back on. there are still more than 160,000 homes just on long island. in the dark tonight. folks in oceanside are told the electricity might be back by the middle of next week. meantime, they fill the giant dumpsters with the water log possessions, wet furniture, rugs, rotting drywall. in the hopes of drying out and saving their homes. bret? >> bret: amazing stories. rick, thank you. stay tuned the latest from overseas as "special report" continues after this.
3:19pm
a hybrid? most are just no fun to drive. now, here's one that will make you feel alive. meet the five-passenger ford c-max hybrid. c-max says ha. c-max says wheeee. which is what you get, don't you see? cause c-max has lots more horsepower than prius v, a hybrid that c-max also bests in mpg. say hi to the all-new 47 combined mpg c-max hybrid. humans -- even when we cross our t's and dot our i's, we still run into problems. namely, other humans. which is why, at liberty mutual insurance, auto policies come with new car replacement
3:20pm
and accident forgiveness if you qualify. see what else mes standard at libertymutual.com. liberty mutual insurance. responsibility. what's your policy?
3:21pm
3:22pm
>> bret: they demand egypt new constitution base on the ruling of islamic law. opponents want to structure the document on principles of shariah. but hardliners incyst it must abide by clerical interpretation. disagreements like that over words and phrases are not unusual in politics. syria's president insists the country is not engaged in zil war. instead, bashar assad tells russian tv he is fighting terrorism through proxxys. iran said it fired in predator drone after crossing to the u.s. air space. aircraft was 60 miles off dost when it was attacked. israel defense minister says iran slowed iranian enrichment timetable to push back the ability to make the nuclear weapons by eight months. the nuclear agency says it will meet with iranians
3:23pm
officials next month to restart stalled negotiations. obama administration is dismissing the stories that long-time domestic policy advisor valerie jarret is rung point on evident to get iran back to the table. senior white house foreign affairs correspondent wendell goler reports. >> both the white house and the state department deny claims that president obama senior advisor jarret is conducting back channel negotiations with iran over the country nuclear program. fueled by papers and bloggers, some u.s. media outlets note jarret was born in iran to american parents and family moved back about the time she started elementary school. one white house official privately called the report laughable and the state department spokeswoman addressed the question on the record. >> there are no secret talks.
3:24pm
y she is a close friend -- she is a close friend from chicago. this is the second time she has been accused of involvement in foreign policy. author richard minator if book "leading from behind" accused him of guiding obama. but they are accusing them of foreign maneuvering. with comments to dmitry medvedev that he would have more flexibility on the european missile defense after the election. administration is denying report of post election u.s. talks and said the talks with the-up security council won't resume until iran satisfied the inspection demand of the international atomic energy agency. bret? >> bret: wendell goler at the state department. thank you. the retweeted image in history. we will show it to you next. with president obama re-election workers at one
3:25pm
company never had a prayer until the last one. grapevine is next. hey. hey eddie. i brought your stuff. you don't have to do this. yes i do. i want you to keep this. it'd be weird. take care. you too. so how did it go? he's upset. [ male announcer ] spend less time at gas stations with best in class fuel economy. it's our most innovative altima ever. now get a $199 per month lease on a 2013 nissan altima. ♪
3:26pm
introducing the new droid razr maxx hd by motorola. now more than ever droid does.
3:27pm
3:28pm
>> bret: now fresh pickings from the political grape grape. the nation's largest privately owning coal mining company reacted to president obama re-election with a prayer and pink slips. they read it to staff members. lord, forbiv me and anyone --
3:29pm
forgive me and anyone with me in the murray energy corporation for the decisions we're now forced to make to preseven existence of any of the enterprises you have helped us build. wednesday, they laid off 150 people at the company and subsidiaries blaming the obama administration war on coal. we reached out to white house for a response. we told you that "newsweek" is going out of print at the end of the year. look at the cover at one of the last issues showing president obama dressed as napolean with the headline at the top "g.o.p., you're old, you're white, you're history." and another image of president obama, this hugging the first lady in a rally in august went viral after sentbe from the twitter account tuesday night. "washington post" says it was the most retweeted and twitter's history. it calls it a snapshot of modern equal marriage. "the president more than
3:30pm
anything seems to need the hug and depends vulnerable. the obligatory masculine markers of leadership resolve resolved. self-sufficientensy of two people lost in hair love world." later the photograph suggests ideal of mutuality in marriag marriage, unincumbered by older ideas of obsession and obedience that hosts sway in traditional religions. the writer note it went viral the same day that several states endorsed same-sex marriage. it may not be entirely accidental. conservative columnist tweeted, "seriously, this should go down in the annalles to the b.s. hall of fame. " it has been three days since presidential election. we know that people are sick of politics. so here is our first report on the 2016 national cam pape.
3:31pm
john robots with who to watch on the republican side. >> mitt and i want to thank you from the bottom of our hearts. >> if the inside track counts for anything paul ryan has it. pass the readiness test his aides incyst. thoroughly vetted and dialed in the mitt romney fundraising machine. he has the apparatus to run, they say, but add he hasn't yet thought about it. in the next year, three big figures, rob potman, chris christie and marco rubio awful with star power but rubio has extra juice says karl rove. >> hubie browmarco rubio is best communicator, latino and from a battleground state. >> iowa is on his agenda. his spokesman told fox news it's too soon to think about 2016. >> he is focused on work in
3:32pm
the senate. christie said he was too busy with sandy to think about this woke's election let alone '16. >> move forward in our recovery efforts. >> strong women could populate the republican field. kelly ayotte of new hampshire. nikki haley and martinez. bobby jindal, bob mcdonald amend scotand scott walker. watch who knows to battl battleground. >> candidates that spend a lot of time in iowa, new hampshire, south carolina, in 2013 and '14 are making a mistake. >> on the democratic side, joe biden could take one more shot though he would be 73. warner and mccain of virginia. new york cuomo. maryland to malley. bill clinton programnance in the fall campaign is any indication hillary could stage a comeback. >> hillary is getting older now. her organization is a little bit leaner than it was.
3:33pm
but she also has to keep in mind it's tough to have three consecutive terms for one party. >> whomever becomes the republican contender has a high bar to leap. how to unite the republican party in face of the demographic shifts that increasingly favor the democrats. bret? >> bret: john, thank you. it may be too early for me, too. who do you think the front run her be? let me know on twitter. @bretbaier. david axelrod is putting his money where his mustache is. he says he is willing and will shave his mustache of 40 years on live television if he can raise $1 million for epilepsy research by the end of the month. axelrod's daughter has the condition. last month he vowed to shave off the mustache if president obama lost battlegrounds but he did not. raise your hand if you saw this coming? david petraeus out at the aye over an extramarital affair. now late breaking developments
3:34pm
about the f.b.i. beingvod in an investigation. the fox all-stars talk about it all when we return. [ male announcer ] what are happy kids made of?
3:35pm
bikes and balloons, and noodles on spoons. a kite, a breeze, a dunk of grilled cheese. catches and throws, and spaghettio's. a wand, some wings, soup with good things. sidewalks and doodles and wholesome noodles. puddles and pails and yes, puppy dog tails. for a lunch like this, there's a hug and a kiss. because that's what happy kids are made of. campbell's. it's amazing what soup can do.
3:36pm
3:37pm
you can't be in the agency. you can't be in the c.i.a. and hide a secret like that. it puts you in an extremely vulnerable position. he is leading the men and women of the c.i.a. >> c.i.a. director petraeus resiped with this letter. "yesterday afternoon i went to white house and asked the president to be allowed for personal reasons to resign from my position as the director of the c.i.a. after being married for over 37 years i showed, dreamily poor judgment by engaging in an extra marital affair. such behavior is unacceptable, both as a husband, as the leader of an organization such as ours." this an the president graciously accepted my resignation."
3:38pm
he is out at the c.i.a. late this afternoon we learned more about this. in fact, this came as the f.b.i. was part of the investigation. the extramarital atary we're told was with a paula broadwell seen in this picture, traveling with david petraeus. she was actually a biographer. wrote a book about petraeus and revealed she was having this affair. he was having this affair with her in the course of an investigation. f.b.i. was investigating a broader case unrelated to their affair. in the course of the investigation, broadwell's name came up and the f.b.i. followed that and believed that possibly petraeus was some sort of victim of blackmail. could have been a security breach. there was no evidence of that and f.b.i. was involved from the beginning. the president accepted david
3:39pm
petraeus' resignation and it to testify ins before benghazi hearings up on capitol hill. we're told he will not testify. he could be compelled to testify. let's bring in panel. steve hayes for "weekly standard." charles lane, opinion writer for ""washington post" post." syndicated columnist charles krauthammer. steve? >> well, this raises many, many questions. when did the f.b.i. first learn of the affair? when did the president and his advisors first learn of the affair? most importantly a question i'm hearing from people on capitol hill, in the intelligence community is it possible that affair had anything to do with --
3:40pm
>> loss of audio ] washington, this -- [ loss of audio ] three days later petraeus testified in front of the house intelligence community and said that these were the questions asked. >> bret: other people we talked to said it wasn't about benghazi. here is what bolton said about the testify. >> nobody should operate under an illusion that congress won't get the story on benghazi. maybe it won't be on thursday but he was the director of the c.i.a. when it happened. >> i suppose john ballton knows what he is talking
3:41pm
about. he will be called to testify. this is one of the most dro mattic developments i think i have ever soon on national security. the director of central intelligence involved in an extramarital affair holding the highest security clearances. what an end to an incredible career of david petraeus. probably the most harolded general of the generation, in both iraq wars confidants of presidents and someone who the administration, the obama team early on thought as a possible rival to the presidency in 2012. one of the things that will probably come out and people will be looking in to is the whole relationship between the white house and david petraeu
3:42pm
petraeus. how all of these things fit together. extraordinary story. >> i want the follow up and say we will unravel all the threads of this in time. this is the first few hours but it's worth noting what we know. this is the end of a career of a truly great american. he did something that hadn't been done by a general since the korean war. when mccarer this by a matthew saved a war -- managed to save a career. and he did that. iraq was a lost war. it was headed for chaos. unending trouble for us, and he pulled off a surge that rescued the war. what happened after in iraq and korea are other stories but that is undeniable. greatest achievement and he pulled it off in afghanistan.
3:43pm
whatever happens and whatever we learn, this is a real tragedy. the other thing, there is no way this will get in way of the benghazi story coming out. in an odd way and discouraging way, now that the story is attached to a scandal it will be a story that will be pursued by the media. they were holding five protect obama before and perhaps out of lack of interest but given nature of journallism it will be become the hottest story around. main stream papers did not show any interest in the paper up to re-election. it will unravel. >> bret: steve? >> petraeus friends and associates are saying that he was looking forward to testifying. the obvious question is why can't he? he was really looking to testifying before his
3:44pm
resignation, there is nothing to keep him from testifying now as private citizen and telling the american public what he knows about what happened. we have been talking about the benghazi story for eight weeks and it's a critical story. it was well before the petraeus scandal. it is afterwards and it could explain the gaps that we took as inexplicable, it may explain it. but we need to hear from him. if he is looking forward to testify he ought to. >> bret: president put out a statement saying today accepted the res ig neigh of director of central intelligence agency and confident the c.i.a. will thrive and carry out the essential mission. i have the ju utmost confidence of the acting director of the c.i.a. to work every day to keep the nation safe. going forward my thoughts and prayers with dave and holly petraeus who has done so much to help military families through her own work. i wish them the best in this difficult time. holly has done a lot with
3:45pm
military families. sad part of this story. michael morrell takes over as c.i.a. we don't know the extent of how active they are but one would think they're very active all over the world. >> the agency, yeah, of course. this has to be demoralizing to the rank and file in the agency. they have been through a lot of directors in recent years and hear your top man was involved in something like this, doing something that you, in the rank and file would have been disciplined for. >> there is the timing aroundbe the election. if the reason he resign and i believe it is, he felt he had done something he needed to as a matter of honor resign over and also the fact that keeper of secret he is had been compromised, why if this had been going on and known by the f.b.i. is there a resignation that waits until election day. compromise the country as a
3:46pm
result of the compromise. the resignation has to come right away. if it's held up to election day that means again the charge at the white house levied against republicans for months politicizing national security. that in and of itself is important question. >> bret: if we find out that the white house knew about the affair, that the f.b.i. had this well before election day, the implications of that? >> implications of that are extraordinary. if robert mueller knew about this going back weeks or months at some of the information coming out suggests how does he keep that? if it compromises national security today, it compromised it on the day we learned he was having an affair. he should have been confronted immediately by that. if mueller kept it from the president orpet kept it from the country -- or if the president kept it from the country a huge scandal. >> bret: we'll follow it on foxment next up, the president
3:47pm
talks compromise sort of as he looks over the fiscal cliff. orr had to cost a fortune. nobody said an all-in-one had to be bulky. or that you had to print from your desk. at least, nobody said it to us. introducing the business smart inkjet all-in-one series from brother. easy to use, it's the ultimate combination of speed, small size, and low-cost printing.
3:48pm
3:49pm
3:50pm
i have invited leaders of both parties to white house next week to start to build consensus around the challenges that we can only solve together. >> i'm hopeful that product tiff conversations can begin soon, so that we can forge an agreement that can pass the congress. >> if we are serious about reducing deficit we have to combine spending cut with revenue. that's asking wealthy americans to pay more in taxes. >> raising tax rates will slow down our ability to create jobs that etch says they want. >> i am open to compromise. open to new ideas. committed to solving the fiscal challenges.
3:51pm
but i refuse to accept any approach that isn't balanced. >> bret: president and the mouse speaker back and forth on the issue of taxes. we stare at the fiscal cliff at the end of the year. back with the panel. charles? >> i think if you listen to nuances in the language it looks as if they're dancing around the com compromise. they offered a peace pipe at the beginning. he would raise tax on wealthy. republicans agree on that as a matter of tact reform. the president incysted that the rates have to go up for top 2%. if he claims it east a wedge in the debt it's ridiculous. cbo estimates $80 billion a year. we have deficit of $1.1 trillion every year. it would reduce the deficit by
3:52pm
$1.1 trillion to $1 $1.02 trillion. it's 7 cents on the dollar. for obama it's symbolism, punitive to say we'll stick it to the rich. if you listen to the statement he talked about the revenue and stayed away from rates. >> bret: said the central question in the election debated over and over again and the white house says he will veto anything that extends the bush era tax cut for top 2% of wage earners. >> but he also says i'm not wedded to every detail. all i want is to raise revenu revenue. they had to cables and one was aggressive and the other was resilltory. they asked what to do and they said ignore the aggressive one. they answered conciliatory one. so i say aggress the conciliatory suggestion
3:53pm
revenues and try to work on deductions eliminated. >> chuck? >> charles, as usual, is talks sense. more sense than usual because he and i agree on this. yes, they are dancing around a compromise. the key to is it the word "rates." john boehner comes back with don't raise taxes. there is a study out by the tax policy center. if you hold the tax rate, cap deduction at $50,000 a year. you raise $750 billion over ten years. it's like john boehner agreed to in priest negotiations. other members saying hey, we can cut a deal. the key, the republicans move that way on taxes. what will the president deliver on entitlements? that is boehner's bottom line he can't move off of it.
3:54pm
he has the get something real on spending. >> bret: that is what republicans never saw in hardcore, on papeer the last negotiations. >> house republicans are skeptical they'll see anything significant about it now or the short term. what is more likely is a short-term compromise and revisit broader tax reform, sometime down the line. they are trying to get out in front of what they see is inevitable. they want to avoid the tax rate that. they see is punitive. and so they are trying to get ahead of that. being open and signaling publicly, celebrateing they're open to additional revenues they come without increases in rates. i don't know if it will end up in a compromise but they will incyst on seeing more from the
3:55pm
white house. >> the first back and forth, though, promising? >> it is. each side could have held ground and gone to negotiations without having concedeed anything. boehner has been speaking about revenues and obama has implying he could drop the rates issue to make it revenues, not sure if he means it. the beginning of something. every side understands if you go over the cliff, eleven be tarnished really severely. republican and democrat. >> bret: that is it for this round. but stay tuned for time thoughts from the panel about the election. in america tay we're running out of a vital resource we need
3:56pm
to compete on the global stage. what we need are people prepared for the careers of our new economy. by 2025 we could have 20 million jobs without enough college graduates to fill them. that's why at devry university, we're teaming up with companies like cisco to help make sure everyone is ready with the know-how we need for a new tomorrow. [ male announcer ] make sure america's ready.
3:57pm
[ male announcer ] alka-seltzer plus presents the cold truth. i have a cold, and i took nyquil, but i'm still "stubbed" up. [ male announcer ] truth is, nyquil doesn't unstuff your nose. no way. [ male announcer ] sorry. alka-seltzer plus fights your worst cold symptoms plus has a fast acting decongestant to relieve your stuffy nose. [ sighs ] thanks! [ male announcer ] you're welcome. that's the cold truth! [ male announcer ] alka-seltzer plus. ♪ oh what a relief it is! ♪ [ male announcer ] to learn more about the cold truth and save $1 visit alka-seltzer on facebook.
3:58pm
>> bret: finally tonight, usually we have a friday lightning round. we did not. usually we have a kicker right here. we will not. so we thought we would end the week with some final thoughts from the panel on election 2012. charles? >> well, it was a rough week for conservatives. we did not -- we lost the
3:59pm
presidency but, on the other hand, if we get really depressed we can always go to denver and get high. now, tweet alert. before you tweet, please, that was a joke. [ laughter ] >> bret: okay. >> i wish i had something that funny. the polls closed late out on the west coast. i don't think quite enough results have been paid in california. the democratic party captured two thirds in both houses of the state legislature out there as well as winning a substantial increase in income taxes to pay for new education spending. governor gerri brown the democratic party have an opportunity now to governor pure blue and we will see how that works out and they will own it. >> that's going to end well. i think what's needed most about this election is perspective. after the 2008 election, many people, conventional wisdom in washington pronounced the death of conservatism. it was time for the republic party to remake itself and two years later on the backs of the tea party, conservatives rose again, historical gains in congress. there are some c